Political props prove puerile

 |  668 Comments

Hudak tax wheel.jpg
Imagine the discussion at the meeting where this was first proposed . . . .
"We need something to get the voters excited about all those damn taxes the Liberals have added!"
"Hey, I've seen people get excited on game shows. Let's do a game show!"
"Yeah, we can have one of those wheelie things that go clackety-clack!"
"Brilliant!"

Here is some free election advice to the leaders of all the parties: mixing props and politics is a bad idea. It rarely works and if it does, it never works as well as you hope it will.

Tim Hudak has now begun to take his tax wheel on the road and the reporters can barely stifle their groans at its corniness.

Aside from the frivolity of the prop, characterizing McGuinty as the "Tax Man" could become a petard upon which Hudak hoists himself. It begins a conversation about fiscal reality that will eventually lead to the fact that Hudak's own numbers don't add up. Perhaps McGuinty should start running around with a prop of a giant calculator.

Stockwell jet ski.jpg
But Hudak isn't the worst offender at using props. At least he tried to attach real meaning to his piece. The image of Stockwell Day driving up on a jet ski wearing a skin-tight wetsuit still causes people to shiver and cringe.

The only truly effectively prop that has been employed in Canadian politics was against Stockwell day himself, when Warren Kinsella brought a stuffed Barney toy onto the set of Canada AM in 2000 to poke fun at Day's stated belief that man walked with the dinosaurs.

General rule of thumb: keep the props in the trunk.


Hello, who's this?

 |  1373 Comments



Remember him?

Dalton McGuinty has kept an extremely low profile for the past few months. Earlier Liberal campaign videos avoided showing McGuinty's image (although they did feature his voice). Obviously the Liberals saw something potentially damaging in including him in their early forays into the media, but why change this strategy now?

Well, with the summer ending and the writ to be dropped in less than two weeks, it was inevitable that he'd have to begin showing his face sooner or later.

However, the mid-August polling done by Nanos shows that McGuinty's personal numbers are rebounding. Look at the chart below gauging trustworthiness of the provincial party leaders.

trust graph.jpg


And this one asking which provincial party leader has the best vision for Ontario.

vision graph.jpg

Now neither of these questions addresses whether those polled would vote for the Liberals, but it does show that Dalton can stop hiding now and come out and play. Expect to see more of him over the next few weeks.
crushed city.jpg

In what was probably the worst horse trade Ontarians have ever seen, Mike Harris swapped some Provincial responsibilities for Municipal ones as part of his Common Sense Revolution. While the Province took on the funding of school boards, cities were left to pay for a myriad of social programs, leading to skyrocketing property taxes across Ontario.

Over the past eight years this has been eased somewhat by a gradual uploading from the province. So far the Liberals have lifted 75% of the cost of public health costs from municipalities. And if you have faith in the Liberals' numbers, they claim that given the opportunity that by 2018 they will have uploaded $2.5 billion that would have otherwise landed on local property taxpayers.

This is in sharp contrast to Tim Hudak's proposal to cancel the user-pay eco-tax and place that $300 million burden on municipalities.

But probably the greatest fear from our Municipal leaders is that because Hudak's numbers don't add up, and that he will have to turn to villages, towns and cities to make up for the shortfall. The Liberals claim that there is a $14 billion hole in Hudak's platform and that mayors are justified in their concern.

What does Tim say? Well, he says that he will not honour the Liberals commitment to the $1.5 billion uploading agreement with the municipalities, but on the other hand he promises not to start downloading again as he and Harris did back in the Common Sense days.

[More concerns about the uploading/downloading issue continue to be raised.]

New ONDP radio ad

 |  416 Comments



Here is the newest radio ad from the Ontario New Democratic Party. Unlike the recent Liberal and Conservative salvos, it looks like Andrea Horwath has decided to focus on the positive. Is there a place for forward-looking, positive messaging on a political landscape dominated with negative ads? We shall see.

So what are the issues going to be?

 |  899 Comments

election signs.jpg
A recent poll by Forum Research shows Tim Hudak's Tories finally dipping in the polls, falling from 41 per cent, past the magic 40 mark, down to 38 per cent. The Liberals and NDP both picked up 2 points and the Greens slipped down by one.

Although it's only been one poll reporting what is really a fairly small change in the middle of a typically quiet summer, it does seem significant as Hudak has been the Teflon man until this point. Many are pointing to the revelation that Hudak has signed a petition to end abortion funding in Ontario as the reason for his party's drop in popularity. His promise to get rid of Local Health Integration Networks (LHINs) can certainly be seen as a way of axing funding for abortions.

What other issues are emerging as possible election touchstones?

The multi-billion dollar Samsung green energy deal signed by Dalton McGuinty might continue to make headlines. The Liberals just renegotiated the deal to shave $327 million off the deal and they are selling it as a good deal made better. The Tories vow to scrap the deal regardless of the financial penalty or job losses. Unable to restrain is usual apolitical self, David Suzuki himself as jumped into the fray and rained all over Hudak's threat.

As an election issue, the HST has had a much quieter landing in Ontario than it has in B.C. but that hasn't stopped both the Conservatives and the NDP from banging that drum. While neither has gone so far as to pledge to repeal or scrap the new tax, both have promised to remove it from some services such as electricity. While both parties are championing HST reform, this one really seems to be Horwath's issue.

Healthcare has been a pretty quiet issue as of late. While the E-health spending scandal still resonates, the Liberals have rolled out the promise of both new and expanded hospitals and neither the NDP nor the Conservatives are fighting very hard on that front.

Similarly, Education has been an issue with little attention. The closest we get to this being an major issue is the topic of the Early Learning initiative. The Liberals want to continue the gradual roll out, the NDP want the process sped up, and the Conservatives say the fate of the program rests on the health of the provinces finances. No big feud here.

A dark horse issue in the upcoming election could also be spectre of Stephen Harper. A video of a BBQ attended by Harper and Toronto mayor Rob Ford (one where the discussion of a Conservative Toronto/Ontario/Canada triple play was openly discussed) was taken down from YouTube after much negative reception. The idea of having Conservatives rule both the House of Commons as well as the Ontario Legislature isn't sitting well with too many Ontarians, but is it enough to affect votes? Well, McGuinty has already begun to run with it.

What issues do you think will dominate this election? Your comments are welcome.

Teachers on the tube

 |  500 Comments

Manitoba Teachers commercial.jpg
Anyone in Ontario who has been watching the NHL playoffs on the satellite feed from Manitoba will have seen the brilliant commercial from the Manitoba Teachers. It is part of their Working to make a difference in students' lives campaign.

The commercial features a parent visiting a classroom and noting the positive changes in public education. It is a straight-forward, simple and friendly message. Kudos to the Now Group for their vision in producing the spot.

Watch the video here.


Tim Hudak's education checklist

 |  1289 Comments

check list.jpg
Everyone knows that Dalton McGuinty has crowned himself the Education Premier. We can assume that the Liberals will push their Education agenda hard during the campaign as they have gained certain success there.

But Tim Hudak can't hide from the issue of Education. Aside from his party's dismal and clumsy handling of Education under Harris and Eves that he must somehow shake off, Hudak actually needs some platform planks in this area and the Conservatives' Changebook does mention a few.

Here are some of the boxes Hudak hopes to check off in Education if he is elected premier:

  • iPads in the classroom: Now this is just silly. Could ipads be useful for some students in some classrooms for certain tasks? Sure. But to throw out the name of the most popular computer fad of the moment and expect it to hold some credibility is wishful thinking. This promise sounds hollow and lacking in any real thought.
  • Giving principals more control: Now Tim's father was a principal so I am sure that he has been well informed on the frustrations of what is certainly a difficult job. Apparently this point deals with principals having more discretion over how money is spent within the school. Who is this promise meant to appeal to? Principals, I guess.
  • Reinstate phonics: Oh please, not this again. Okay, for anyone who is not already aware of this, I will say it one more time, "PHONICS IS ALREADY TAUGHT IN ONTARIO SCHOOLS." It never went away. It has always been part of a balanced curriculum used to teach literacy.
  • Give teachers the right to ban cell phones: Hudak had to include this one after he rallied against McGuinty's comment that cellphones can be helpful in classrooms. It's a stupid move. Parents equip their children with cellphones so they can reach them - it is a safety issue. Also, are teachers going enact a ban themselves? How many teachers took Mike Harris up on his offer to allow them to suspend students for swearing in the classroom? That's right, none.
There are more planks in Hudak's Education platform, but most are similarly weak. Don't expect the Conservatives to get votes for these ideas or their promise to invest even more money in Education than McGuinty has. There are too many skeletons in this closet and the new ideas are pale and sickly.
chain gang.jpg
Straight from the Ontario P.C. platform document, Changebook.

criminals 9in.jpgAre Ontario voters interested in having criminals cleaning up their communities? Well the idea certainly made a splash in the media where it was treated quite negatively:
The Star was dead set against it: Think twice about chain gangs
The Globe and mail mocked the idea: Gossamer, fairy dust, and chain gangs
Even the National Post scoffed at the idea: Tim Hudak the pretender wants Ontario back on the chain gang

Despite all this bad press, Hudak continues to champion the idea, much like four years ago when John Tory refused to listen to popular opinion and stuck to his guns on funding private religious schools.

Here is one wag's take on the topic:



Ontario for dummies.jpg
You've been waiting for it and now it's here! The all all mostly kind of new platform document from the Ontario PCs. Over the next week or so, we will browse through it, focusing on certain sections and asking you what you think about each plank.

In the meantime, download your own copy here and start reading!

Hudak eduction.jpg
Oh, this doesn't bode well. The Ontario Conservative Party continues to struggle with the issue of Education. First Harris appointed a high school drop-out to be the Education Minister. Then John Tory thought voters would like their taxes to fund private religious schools. Now Tim Hudak has trouble spelling the word.

This picture was taken from the live stream video of the Ontario Conservative Party convention this weekend.